A Blogger’s 2010 Resolution

by Andrew McAfee on January 4, 2010

Over the past few days I’ve read posts by Timothy Gowers on his polymath project and by Lewis Shepard on the most recent failure to connect the dots among available pieces of intelligence in order to head off a terrorist attack. The posts themselves are excellent, but what really struck me was how thoroughly both authors responded to comments on their blogs.

As Julien Le Nestour and others have pointed out, this is not something I’ve done. I’ve always considered comments important and actively solicited them in most posts, but have rarely responded directly to them. I’ve considered them a way for folk to air their ideas rather than to engage in a dialogue with me.

I see now that this was shortsighted, and that interacting with commenters is a great way to make a blog more dynamic and valuable for its readers. So my resolution for 2010 is to be a more active responder to what others are saying here. I can’t promise that I’ll reply to every comment, but I will reply to more of them.

How can I best do this? What advice do you have about how to respond well to blog comments? Leave a comment, please; I’ll use it as an opportunity to start practicing…  ;)

And Happy New Year!

  • http://theobvious.typepad.com/blog/ euansemple

    I've been guilty of the same thing Andrew! Sometimes I think that me keeping out the way makes it easier for readers to talk amongst themselves. Funnily enough one my best recent comment threads was around the terrorist threat and as I said to my wife I love nothing better than when a post kicks of a great, grown-up conversation about stuff that matters.

    http://euansemple.com/theobvious/2010/1/2/terro…

  • digiphile

    I was blown away by how thoroughly Shepard responded. Sometimes, it makes sense to write another post. In many cases, addressing point by point is easier, at least for me. I know that responding builds community and demonstrates that the blog's owner(s) are listening to the readers and addressing concerns. Great posts stimulate great comments, as demonstrated by Shepard's example. Often, I find that in situations like that, the most valuable insights, links and opinion may be found in those reactions, not the original work.

    Advice? Thank visitors for taking the time to comment – that's a gift of social capitol – even if it's a negative response. Respond to constructive criticism substantively, moderate personal attacks out of the stream. Highlight truly great comments with “UPDATE” or by tweeting them out or linking to them in later posts.

    Avoid flamewars that don't have anything to do with a topic. And keep a sense of humor: online interaction often leaves traditional notions of courtesy or etiquette in the digital dustbin.

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    I love that, too, and I'm also going to start participating more in the conversations that spring up in the comments section of my posts.
    Always a pleasure to hear from you, Euan – Happy New Year!

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    Thanks for the great advice, and for your series of perceptive comments here over many months; they're much appreciated.
    (how'd I do? ;) )

  • http://twitter.com/BarryJOGorman Barry O'Gorman

    A little bit of a conundrum. The quality of the content is what generates the feedback and retains the audience. There generally is plenty to be gained from interacting with the audience – but the cost is reduced time to generate new, original, content.

  • http://circaspecting.typepad.com/ scott davis

    AM – this is a powerful engagement idea. I need to do the same on my blog. It reminds me of the essential skill for dinner parties: keep the conversation flowing. Find something interesting in what the partner says, then (1) express interest and ask for elaboration, or (2) highlight a cool extension of what the partner said.

  • digiphile

    You did well, Prof. Now, how do I get you to come over and grace the comments on my blog?

  • http://twitter.com/mjayliebs Mitch Lieberman

    Nice resolution – really. The words that pop out for me, and then putting together are: Engage(ment) leads to a great Dynamic, which increases the Value. I try to understand how readers make the leaps they do (not sure I get there). This thought process may aid you in future posts. I will certainly come back to this post and see what others have to say as well.

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    Yep – I think one key is to keep replies short, so as not to use up to much authorial bandwidth… ;)

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    Mitch, thanks for the tips – I will keep them in mind.

  • http://lewisshepherd.wordpress.com/ Lewis Shepherd

    Andy – great post, excellent resolution which I have to remind myself of periodically. The example of mine which you linked to is a great example of a blogpost being not just supplemented but superceded by the combined “discussion.” Sort of like a slow-motion google wave thread; one of the things I notice is that a good blog/comments thread really supports asynchronicity well, including across days and months. I get folks finding an old blogpost through a search engine, coming in and leaving a comment, and my response will spark another round of discussion. Your content is similar – tremendous value that holds up over time, so I enjoy reading your “old” posts as well.

    Thanks for the shout-out, much appreciated. Look forward to seeing you again soon. -lewis

  • http://kyle.mathews2000.com/blog Kyle Mathews

    Fred Wilson does a great does a really good job over at http://avc.com. He'd be a good model to follow.

  • https://gstrzok.wordpress.com/ G. Lance Strzok

    Andrew,

    This is good news to hear from you, and I think you will come to be glad you made it and followed up on it. I would simply say that you are going to find comments that are confusing, or appear of little value. When you find one confusing or potentially useless (but not outright dumb), you may want to consider simply asking them to refine it into a better question or rephrase the response. This will illicit more conversation, and may bring to light the point they were really taking the time to try to make.

    Best wishes on your NYR.

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    Great idea. I also find that I get a LOT more from comments the second time I read them.

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    Thanks – I'll check it out…

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    The shoutout was richly deserved. Thanks for all your good work and sharp thinking. I'm sure we'll see each other in 2010…

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    These are hugely important and rare skills. Too many people just want to talk about themselves, to the detriment of all involved… ;)

  • http://removebellyfat.thetopquest.com/ how-to-reduce-belly-fat

    I like the idea where every actions stay within our own domain. UI is getting better.

  • dennishampton

    Thanks for the information and great content. I am always going through the internet looking for good content to get ideas for my home based business opportunity web sites and future articles on this general subject. Again thanks for the excellent content and a nice looking web site.
    Dennis
    http://powerin2.info

  • 123456789sbb

    wedding dresses,wedding gowns,bride dresses,bridesmaids dresses,evening dresses,bridal gowns,flower girl dresses
    Wedding Gowns
    Formal Gowns
    Cocktail Gowns
    Find the wedding dress designer and wedding dress that's right for you! Browse dresses from
    Bridesmaid Gowns
    Evening Gowns
    View our selection of exquisite, handmade gowns and dresses for your wedding
    Wedding Dresses, Wedding Shoes and Wedding Accessories from wedding shop, the UK's finest collection of designer wedding dresses.
    Use the wedding dress and
    cheap wedding
    wedding dresses
    wedding shop

  • edmigo

    I suggest to let everyone rate the comments without needing to sign in. You and readers can find and respond to more important comments quickly since comments get more rating. After all, not every comment is worth a response.

  • lihaoxj16

    tiffany jewelry
    Choose, buy and shop for on sale tiffany jewelry including Tiffany & Co Silver Necklace, Pendants, Bangles, Bracelets, Earrings, Rings and Accessories.
    tiffany co
    Tiffany Jewellery offering bangle Jewellery, bracelet jewelry, eardrop jewelry, necklace jewelry, ring jewelry, finger ring jewelry and earring jewelry
    tiffany
    tiffany and co
    links of london
    links london
    Tiffany Style Silver Jewelry: Rings, Earrings, Necklaces, Bracelets and more Tiffany Jewellery at low prices.

  • http://andrewmcafee.org/blog amcafee

    I like that idea, but I don't know if the DISQUS system enables comment ratings…

  • http://www.jrconsumer.com/ RV Ratings

    you are having such good realization there…

  • mortgagedebts

    The advance technology is very helpful for me and this is first site which impress me so i like it.
    Advanced Technology

  • mortgagedebts

    The advance technology is very helpful for me and this is first site which impress me so i like it.
    Advanced Technology

  • http://www.register-domainname.in Domain registration

    Really awesome post and i appreciate your work.

  • http://www.register-domainname.in/ Register domain name

    Really a great idea and i appreciate your work. Thanks for sharing.

  • http://thesoftshops.com thesoftshops.com

    Good!

Previous post:

Next post: